Copyright © 2025 by Christie Winter

All rights reserved.

No portion of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher or author, except as permitted by U.S. copyright law.

a candle in the window

Chapter 12: The Candleman Returns

The air in the office was barely habitable, as if the blackout curtains had succeeded not just in choking out light but also any air that might have once been clean. Evelyn stepped through the doorway, boots finding the soft spots in the floorboards, and closed the door behind her with the gentlest possible click. The ancient wood yielded, though not without a complaint, and she found herself standing at parade rest in the sort of darkness that did not so much conceal as compress.

A single lantern provided illumination, its light caught and thrown in unpredictable directions by the battered tin reflector. It left the corners of the room in black ambiguity but served the battered desk in the center with a spotlight precision. The effect was theatrical, and she suspected this was not accidental.

Inspector Reid was already at the desk, hands braced on either side of an envelope that looked too important for local business. His coat was buttoned to the throat, and the sharp, chemical tang of his aftershave cut through the fog of coal dust and old paper. He did not look up immediately, instead smoothing the envelope on the blotter as if it might contain a hidden seam that would yield if pressed just so.

She waited, allowing herself the luxury of a full scan: the desk, the heavy shadows, the outline of an army-issue radio in the corner, silent for now. Reid’s notebook was open to a blank page, his pencil aligned with the edge of the blotter. The staging was perfect, right down to the three chairs, one for the inspector, one for her, and one that remained, per custom, empty.

He broke the tableau by flicking the envelope open with his thumb. The noise of tearing paper was loud in the hush. Only then did he glance up, catching her in the act of studying him. “Miss Harcourt,” he said, voice registering just above the threshold where it might crack. “I apologize for the hour.”

She shook her head, wiped at her temple, and felt the dampness there. Rain still clung to her hair, beads tracking along the fine bones of her face to collect at the angle of her jaw. She brushed them away with the back of her wrist and approached the desk, holding herself in the posture she’d used for hospital matron interviews: reserved, alert, unflappable.

Reid gestured at the single chair opposite, but she hesitated, hand resting lightly on the backrest as she waited for him to speak. He did, eventually, but not before unfolding the letter and aligning it with the edge of the desk. “There’s been a development,” he said. His eyes were flat, shielded, the color of slate under river ice. “London believes Captain Ashcroft may have survived.”

Her heart, accustomed to its new wartime rhythm, jerked sideways in her chest. She froze, hand still on the chair, and for a moment the world compressed to the outline of the envelope, the lantern’s trembling shadow, the sound of her own blood in her ears. She gripped the edge of the chair, knuckles whitening. “That’s not possible,” she said, the words out before her mind could arrange them for public consumption. “He- he died at Dunkirk. There was a funeral.”

Reid watched her, not for signs of deception but for some other quality. “They never recovered the body. Not conclusively. There was a report, but it was… unsubstantiated.” The lantern guttered, and the shadow of the envelope leapt up the wall behind him, a pale, rectangular ghost.

Evelyn released the chair and reached for the desk instead, needing something solid under her fingers. The wood was slick with a film of old polish and new sweat. She locked her elbows and drew a steadying breath, but her lungs would not fill completely, as if the blackout curtains had spread to her chest. She looked at the envelope, then at Reid. “What do they want from me?”

He tapped the envelope with his forefinger, a single, decisive motion. “They want to know what you remember. About Ashcroft. About your brother’s correspondence with him. About the candle, the codes, all of it.”

The room was constricted. She thought of the old field hospital, the way morphine slowed a man’s heart to a crawl, how every word spoken around his bed became amplified and inescapable. She forced herself to focus on the present, on the physical: the cold radiating off the window, the smell of wet wool from her own coat, the invisible architecture of tension that filled the room.

Evelyn pulled herself upright, refusing to let the tremor in her hands transfer to her voice. “There’s nothing to remember,” she said. “Ashcroft was just a patient. My brother corresponded with a dozen men after the war. It was nothing.”

Reid’s mouth quirked, just enough to acknowledge the inadequacy of her answer. “London disagrees,” he said. He held up the envelope, then set it down so that the address faced her. “They believe Ashcroft is alive. And that your brother knew it all along.”

Her vision narrowed to the black, blocky letters of the address, the hard angles of the stamp. She felt the ghost of a headache stir at the base of her skull, a precursor to the migraines that used to plague her in childhood. She did not speak, not yet. She could not trust her voice.

Reid allowed the silence. He folded his hands atop the envelope, the gesture both invitation and threat. “You don’t have to say anything now. But I will need your statement.” Evelyn nodded, once, and released the desk. Her hand left a perfect, wet imprint on the blotter. She stared at it, watched the edges darken and spread, then dried her palm on the lining of her coat.

She met his eyes and found them unchanged. Not cruel, not even stern, just fixed, like a doctor’s in the moment before the needle went in. “Thank you,” he said, as if she had given him something. She stepped away from the desk, boots finding their echo in the floorboards. As she reached the door, she stopped, wanting to ask something. But the words did not come together. She left instead, closing the door behind her as gently as she’d entered.

In the corridor, she paused, one hand braced against the wall, and waited until her heart decelerated to a manageable speed. She thought of Ashcroft, of Tom, of the candle in the window, and of the code that seemed to run under every word, every gesture, every piece of news that arrived from London.

She let the rainwater drip from her hair onto the flagstones and did not move for a very long time.

She stood in the corridor, waiting for the tremor to pass. When it did not, she forced her body upright and returned to the office, the door a black rectangle against the edge of consciousness. This time, she did not bother with the ceremony. She stepped in, closed the door, and stayed by the threshold, as if proximity to the outside air would anchor her to the present.

Inspector Reid had not moved from his seat. The envelope was gone, replaced by a notepad that already showed two parallel furrows where his pencil had bitten through the paper. To his left, the office’s telegraph receiver, a squat, brass-plated instrument, sat idle on the table, its silence like a held breath.

Evelyn’s vision doubled, for a moment, and the room superimposed itself on a different memory: a hospital ward in Boulogne, the night Ashcroft arrived half-dead and grinning, blood caked in the corner of his mouth. She could feel his hand on her wrist, fever-hot and insistent, and could hear the roughness of his voice as he’d whispered, “Keep the candle burning.” The memory was so sharp that she almost spoke his name aloud.

A sound pulled her back: the slow, deliberate scrape of Reid’s pencil, the faint tick as he set it down. “Are you well, Miss Harcourt?” She nodded, once, then found her voice. “Fine. Just… cold.” He did not believe her, but he left it alone. Instead, he angled his chair to the radio, flipping the switch with a two-fingered motion. The set buzzed, then resolved into the low thrum of static. He listened, head tilted, then twisted the frequency knob with the delicacy of a safecracker.

She watched as he adjusted the set, and her hands remembered the motion, the subtle torque required to dial in the right band. She’d learned from Tom, evenings spent scavenging signals from Paris or Warsaw or the airbases down the coast. Her fingers twitched, recalling the muscle memory.

Then the telegraph receiver clicked, a single, emphatic beat that echoed in the hollow of the room. Reid’s shoulders tensed, and he reached for the notepad, ready. Another click, then three in quick succession. He counted them aloud, sotto voce, as if afraid to draw the message into the real world. Evelyn found herself holding her breath.

The message came in short bursts, followed by long pauses, the code rendered almost musical by the timing. Reid jotted each sequence, translating as he wrote, his lips barely moving. Evelyn moved closer, driven by an urge to see the pattern in the marks before he could speak them.

After a full minute, the clicking stopped. Reid set the pencil down, tapped the side of the notepad twice, and then, very deliberately, read aloud: “Candle lit. Window safe. Repeat. Candle lit. Window safe.”

He looked up, waiting for her to decipher the meaning. She already had. The phrase landed like a fist in her chest, the air forced out and replaced by something sharp and metallic. She reached into her coat and drew out Tom’s cipher notebook, the one she’d smuggled from the house weeks ago. Her hands shook so that the pages trembled, the paper nearly tearing along the creases as she found the relevant entry.

She compared the notations, matched the sequence, and read the translation in her brother’s hand: “Allied agent alive. Await contact.” Below, in the margin, another line: “Keep the candle burning. J.A.” She shut the book, pressed it to her chest, and found herself laughing, a single, brittle sound that left the air even thinner.

Reid stood, and the effect was immediate. The smallness of the office could not contain him. He crossed to her in two strides, not quite invading her space but making it clear that the boundaries had shifted. “You know what this means?” he said, voice as taut as piano wire. She nodded. “Ashcroft is alive.”

Reid’s jaw flexed, a muscle working at the base of his ear. “And your brother isn’t a traitor. He’s a handler.” It should have been a relief, but instead she felt only the slow, spreading ache of dread. “Who else knows?” she asked. Reid shook his head. “Only us. For now.” She looked at him, searching for any sign of duplicity, but saw only the haunted clarity of a man who had spent too many years operating in the penumbra of secrets.

The radio set buzzed again, then fell silent. In the new quiet, every sound was amplified: the drip of condensation from the window, the muffled thump of a lorry somewhere on the street outside, the shallow breathing of two people suddenly and irrevocably joined by knowledge.

She slid the cipher notebook back into her pocket and squared her shoulders. “What do we do now?” she said. Reid smiled, or tried to. “Now, Miss Harcourt, we wait for the next signal. And we hope we’re the first to answer it.” She nodded, but her mind was already racing, mapping the new information onto the old, seeing every possibility as a line of code, a chain of cause and effect with no clear terminus.

She did not sit, did not rest. Instead, she moved to the window, pressed her palm against the cold, and watched the street for any sign that the world outside had changed to match the one inside. She stood there until the light shifted, until the lantern’s wick burned low and the patterns of shadow grew indistinct.

And in the space between those shadows, she saw the ghost of Captain Ashcroft, alive and waiting, candle burning in the window, the code still unbroken.

She paced the length of the office, tracing a path between the two metal filing cabinets that anchored either end of the room. The lantern’s flame, starved for air, flickered and leapt, throwing her shadow in giant, spasmodic waves across the flaking plaster. The scent of burning oil was sharp, nearly acrid, and every third breath she took felt thick with the residue of unresolved tension.

Reid had not moved since the last transmission. He sat, hands clasped in his lap, jaw squared as if by some external force. He watched her, unblinking, the color in his eyes muted by the lantern but still cutting through the half-light with surgical precision. Evelyn rounded on him, planting both hands on the blotter at the center of the desk. “If Ashcroft is alive,” she said, “then Tom isn’t a traitor. He’s working with… ”

“With a ghost,” Reid interrupted. His tone was flat, but the muscles at the edge of his jaw flickered in time with his pulse. “Ashcroft has been presumed dead for two years. If he is broadcasting now, the odds are… ” He let the sentence dangle, unfinished, and tapped the notepad with the eraser of his pencil.

She caught the movement, the impatience beneath it. “The odds are that London got it wrong,” she said. “Or that someone wanted them to think Ashcroft was gone.” Reid lifted the pencil, then set it down again. “Or,” he said, “Ashcroft has turned. And your brother is aiding the enemy, unwittingly or not.”

The statement fell between them with the weight of a verdict. Evelyn felt her chest constrict. “You don’t believe that,” she said, voice barely audible. Reid’s gaze drifted to the floor, then back to her. “What I believe doesn’t matter. The War Office will want proof.”

She drew in a breath, held it, then let it out slowly. The siren started then, distant but insistent, its pitch winding up as it cut through the blackout air. The lantern’s flame danced, then steadied, painting the room in a sickly, unstable blue.

Evelyn crossed to the window and peered through the slit in the blackout curtain. The street below was deserted, the only motion the swirl of mist chasing itself down the gutter. She pressed her palm to the glass, feeling the cold radiate up her arm. Reid joined her at the window, standing so close their knees almost touched. She felt the heat of his body even through the thickness of her coat, the tension running through him like wire.

“We need to find him,” she said, her voice so quiet it barely disturbed the glass. “Before anyone else does.” Reid said nothing. His hand came to rest on the sill, fingers brushing hers for a split second before he pulled back, as if shocked by the contact.

She watched the village, searching for the flicker of a candle in a window, for any sign that someone, somewhere, was waiting for her to decode the message. When she turned back, Reid was still at the window, his posture unchanged, but there was a new set to his shoulders, a resolve that had not been there before.

Evelyn pulled her coat tighter around her frame, buttoning it up to the throat, and stepped toward the door. As she reached for the handle, she hesitated, looking back at Reid. In the uncertain light, his face was unreadable, a cipher in its own right. “Be careful, Miss Harcourt,” he said, the words as much an order as a plea.

She nodded, then slipped into the corridor, closing the door behind her. The chill in the air hit her at once, sharper than before, and she let it brace her as she moved down the stairs and into the wet, dark street.

She paused at the end of the alley, turned once, and looked up at the office window. The lantern was still burning, its glow painting a rectangle on the wall opposite, and within it the silhouette of a man who could not decide whether to trust her or the world they both had inherited.

She smiled, thin and hard, and vanished into the fog, each step measured, each breath tight with purpose. Above her, somewhere in the night, a window waited to be lit. And beneath the silence, the code kept running.