Copyright © 2025 by Christie Winter

All rights reserved.

No portion of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher or author, except as permitted by U.S. copyright law.

a candle in the window

Chapter 16: A Candle Relit

The parlor was smaller than Evelyn remembered, but that was the trick of light and memory. It existed in a permanent state of dusk, curtains cinched tight with clothesline, the only illumination a paraffin lamp set low on the end table. Every wall sagged under the weight of shelves: hymnals in dense procession, municipal histories, seed catalogs and yearbooks, old School Board ledgers, Clara’s private canon of the village’s past and present. At the center, a battered card table had been cleared of its usual tea-service and set for war, though not the kind that showed up in dispatches.

The air was close and salted with the dust of decades; the coal stove did its work, ticking in slow alternation with the clock. On the table, laid out with a precision learned in field hospitals, were the tools of her latest and perhaps last operation: Tom’s cipher notebook, a battered Ordnance Survey map with the margin rubbed raw, three church hymnals with pencil marks in their indices, and a mug of coffee so scorched it tasted of coal dust. Clara had left her alone to work, but not before reminding her, twice, that the patrols sometimes doubled back after the hour.

Evelyn’s right hand moved in increments, pencil hovering over the map as if afraid the slightest pressure might detonate the entire room. Each hymn number from Tom’s code was written in the margin: “38, 19, 128, 54, 11,” and so on. She cross-referenced them to the corresponding hymns, then to the ledger of church events. The system was fiendish in its simplicity, hymn numbers as coordinates, dates as times, and in every line a deliberate, maddening ambiguity, as if Tom had known she would hate him for it.

She lined up the first three points: “Abide with Me” (38), “Lead Kindly Light” (19), “Nearer My God to Thee” (128). Each mapped, in Tom’s hand, to a latitude and longitude she recognized: the south pier, the green at Market Square, and the path above the lime kilns. On the map, when plotted, the points formed a ragged triangle, one vertex extending straight to the margin above the village’s east cliff. The edge of the world.

Her breath, when it returned, was cold and dry. She checked her math, traced each point again, then paused to flex the fingers of her left hand, which had gone numb from the effort of holding the pencil. The world outside was blacked-out, but the fog pressed so thick against the windows that the parlor felt like the inside of a lung. Each inhale tasted of burnt sugar and old ghosts.

She worked the next layer. If the first set of coordinates was the perimeter, the next was the key to its interior. The numbers bled together: “3, 17, 23.” She found them in the index, translated them to the tiny crosses Tom had penciled onto the Survey’s grid. Each time, the result was an intersection just shy of a landmark: a deconsecrated well, the vicarage, a wind-stunted tree that had survived every war for a century.

She set the pencil down, and for a moment, the silence was enough to flatten her chest. Then the wall clock ticked, the stove whined, and the world reconstituted. She sipped the coffee. It tasted worse than before.

Her eyes drifted to the window, where condensation had painted runnels down the glass. Once, when she was small and frightened by the dark, Tom would draw faces in the mist, or ships, or once, a perfect rendering of St. Elwyn’s in the winter. She remembered watching his finger trace the outline, the way he always left a door open, as if the church required not just a threshold but an exit. She had never asked why. Now, she thought she knew.

She turned back to the map. The path was obvious: the next rendezvous was at the cliffside chapel, a shell of a building left to the weather when the living had all fled to safer ground. It was the farthest point from the village, a place even the most persistent patrols would think twice before searching. If there was to be an endgame, it would play out there.

She packed the notebook and the map, then checked the time. Three quarters past midnight. The blackout would last until dawn, but Clara’s caution was not misplaced. Evelyn stood, stretching the fatigue from her back, and ran a hand over the small of her spine where the tension collected.

She was about to douse the lamp when something caught her eye: the edge of a floorboard just beneath the bookcase, slightly raised, the varnish there rubbed flat by decades of pacing. She knelt, eased the board up with her fingernail, and found a cavity the length of her forearm. At the bottom, a wooden box, cheap pine and brass hinges, stained by oil or sweat or both.

She lifted it out and set it on the table. The lid was not locked. Inside: a single white candle, thick as her wrist, and a folded envelope addressed in Clara’s unmistakable schoolmarm script. She opened the letter. The paper was nearly transparent, the ink bled from the pressure of the pen.

Evelyn, dear…

Some truths will see you safe. Others will kill you twice before morning.

Choose carefully.

C.

She let the letter rest on the table, pressed the tip of her finger to the signature, then took the candle from the box. It was heavy and smooth, the wax smelling faintly of honey and dust. She set it upright, then reached for the matches in the cup by the stove.

Her hands did not shake. She struck a match, waited for the sulfur to bloom, then touched it to the wick. The flame caught slow, then quick, then settled into a steady blue-white column. The candle threw shadows up the wall, doubling the outlines of the books and the lamp, turning the parlor into a diorama of itself. She watched as the wax pooled at the base, molten and new, and felt a sense of having crossed an invisible line.

The candle, she realized, was not for the dead but for those who had to walk through the night to find them. She let it burn, just long enough to feel the heat on her palm. Then she pinched it out, replaced the box, and pressed the floorboard back into place. The room resumed its normal geometry, but the memory of the flame lingered in her eyes.

She packed the rest of the supplies: Tom’s notebook, the small lantern Clara had left on the windowsill, her own coat still damp from the run to the church. She checked the pockets for what she knew she’d find: a roll of bandage, the stub of a pencil, a packet of stale biscuits, the detritus of her old life condensed for what might be the last time.

At the door, she paused and looked back at the parlor. The lamp still burned, drawing a trembling oval on the ceiling. The room looked smaller than ever, but this time, she knew it was not the trick of light. It was the world itself, collapsing to a point.

She shut the door behind her, and the click of the latch sounded, in that brief, bright moment, like the start of something inevitable.

The world outside had grown even darker in the hours since Evelyn last walked these lanes. She let the door swing shut and drew the collar of her coat up to her chin, resisting the urge to shiver. The lantern, hooded and kept to a miser’s gleam, illuminated only a hand’s span of cobblestone ahead. Beyond that was nothing, not even the suggestion of horizon. Just the fog, thick and dynamic, a living thing that coiled around her feet and tried, with every gust, to pull her off course.

She paused at the top of the steps, testing the air for sound or movement. The village was in blackout, as always, but the night had an extra quality, as if every inhabitant had drawn one breath and then held it, waiting. The smell was of brine and burnt oil; the fog had come in from the sea, carrying the cold with it, sharp enough to numb the skin on contact.

She stepped off the porch, boots crunching over old gravel. Every ten paces she glanced behind her, checking for the shadow of a patrol or the accidental flash of torchlight. There was none, but still she felt the pressure of unseen eyes, as if the entire village had been instructed to monitor her passage and report back on every deviation.

It was just a feeling. She moved on.

The path to the coast was indirect, winding through the allotments and behind the market square, then down a length of frost-broken concrete to the canal. The canal itself was a dead line of water, frozen at the edges but moving, barely, at the center. She crossed the footbridge, hand tight on the lantern’s handle, each board flexing with her weight and sending an echo into the black.

At the far side, the wind caught her for the first time, billowing her coat and rattling the glass of the lamp. She shielded the flame with her free hand, crouched low until the gust died, then pressed on. The coastal path, when she found it, was little more than a two-man rut cut by years of sheep and the occasional Army truck. It tracked the lip of the cliff, always within hearing of the sea but rarely in sight of it.

She followed the path, head down, the only orientation was the pinprick of her own lantern and the ghostly contour of the hedgerow. The wet grass gave way to cinder, then to a patch of standing water she skirted by memory alone. Somewhere ahead, the cliffside chapel waited, a relic left over from a time when the world was held together by superstition and stone.

The fog deepened, its texture changing from wool to lead. Her ears filled with the white noise of it, every other sound erased or rendered suspect. The lamp guttered once, and for a panicked second she imagined it dead, but a sharp rap to the brass brought it back to life. She adjusted the wick, set her jaw, and walked on.

With each step, the cold worked its way deeper, finding the seams in her coat and the thinness of her gloves. The old wound in her left knee, consequence of too many nights on hospital cots, throbbed in warning. She ignored it. The salt air made her eyes water, the wind blowing it horizontal so that tears stung her cheek and froze there.

She pressed on.

The path curved abruptly, and she nearly missed the turning. The ground here was slick with a runoff from the field above, turning every other step into a negotiation with gravity. She steadied herself against a fencepost, then followed the line of posts until the ground leveled again. Ahead, the fog thinned, revealing the faint suggestion of a stone wall and, beyond it, the outline of the ancient chapel.

She hesitated, breath rasping in her chest. The path split here, a fork she’d overlooked in the planning. To the left, the route dipped toward the lower pasture, a longer but less exposed track. To the right, the path narrowed, skirting the edge of the cliff and disappearing into the fog. The stonework of the wall, patched with generations of lichen and moss, did nothing to disguise the danger. One misstep, and she would tumble straight to the rocks below.

She drew Tom’s notebook from her pocket and flipped it open, shielding the pages from the wind with her body. The notation was clear: “Take the high road, faster, safer after midnight.” She smiled, briefly, at Tom’s optimism, then snapped the book shut and turned right.

The first hundred yards were easy, the path broad enough for two and edged with a low stone curb. But soon it narrowed, the land falling away on the right to a void filled with the dull roar of waves. The wind caught her again, harder this time, and she staggered, nearly losing the lamp. She crouched, set her free hand to the ground, and waited until the gust subsided.

When she stood again, the world was even smaller. Only her own breathing and the weak circle of lantern light were real. She set her feet carefully, heel-to-toe, the way Tom had taught her when they were children, sneaking home along the railway embankment after curfew. The memory gave her a momentary strength. She moved faster, ignoring the sting in her thigh and the ache at her temples.

At the sharpest point of the curve, a slip of the boot sent her skidding half a meter toward the brink. She dropped to one knee, palm pressed flat to the stone, and heard the pebbles skittering down into nothing. She waited, counting to ten, then twenty, then forced herself upright and checked the lamp. Still burning.

She made the rest of the ascent in increments, pausing after every dozen steps to catch her breath and scan the fog for sign of movement. There was none. The only sound was the shudder of the wind and the tireless, unsympathetic music of the sea. At the crest, she found herself suddenly in the clear. The fog, perhaps unwilling to climb any higher, had retreated to the pasture below, leaving the final stretch exposed to the night. The moon, thin and exhausted, hung just above the horizon, painting the old chapel in a light that seemed more memory than phenomenon.

The chapel had been a rumor for most of Evelyn’s life, a waypoint for wanderers and a lightning rod for stories, but never a place for the living. Now, as the fog thinned, it materialized out of the gray with a sudden, architectural certainty: a squat stone box on the last stable ledge of the cliff, roof patched with slabs of old slate, windows slit-narrow and occluded with blackout cloth. The bellcote above had long since lost its bell, and in the dim, noncommittal moonlight, the empty arch was a mouth, ready to sound an alarm at the first misstep.

Evelyn halted at the edge of the property, boots mired in the clutch of saltgrass and coarse mud. Her breath steamed in the air, and for a second she just stood, letting her pulse slow to a manageable speed. She killed her lantern, masking the approach, and let her eyes adjust to the natural dark. The wind, so intent on dislodging her from the world a moment before, now shrank to a fretful murmur, as if even the elements knew it was time for a truce.

She advanced, slowly and carefully, tracking the perimeter with her back pressed to the leeward side of the stone wall. At each window, she stopped, listened, and scanned for movement. The blackout curtains were deployed with wartime discipline; only the small, oblong pane near the altar leaked the faintest suggestion of candlelight, a stub of flame pushing back against the endless cold.

Evelyn circled the building once more, mapping every inch. The north face was all moss and slick algae, treacherous as glass; the east side, facing the drop, was open to the elements, but here the wind had scoured the stone nearly smooth. No fresh footprints, no parked bicycle, no sign of a patrol. Only the faint indent where a heel had pressed into the mud at the door; someone had recently let themselves in.

She crouched at the threshold, ear cocked for any sound from inside. The silence was entire, save for the deep, resonant ticking of her own heart and the distant applause of surf against the cliff. A memory came to her; Tom again, on the eve of some adolescent dare, whispering, “Don’t think, just move.” She mouthed the words and felt them, electric, in her marrow.

She reached for the door. The iron handle was so cold it burned, and for a moment she held it, letting the chill work its way up her arm and into her shoulder. The sensation cleared her mind better than any rationed gin or morphine could have. She was ready. She listened one last time. Nothing.

With her left hand she drew the lantern from under her coat, set the wick to its highest, and thumbed the striker. The flame caught, blue-white and eager, and the glass reflected her face back at her: pale, jaw set, eyes bright and glassy in the half-light. She regarded herself a moment, then turned the knob.

The door did not give easily. She braced her shoulder against it, nudging until the ancient wood and rusted hinge conspired to open just wide enough to admit her frame. The air inside was warmer than the outside, but not by much. It carried the heavy, metallic tang of melted wax and the fainter, older scent of dry rot and lichen. She stepped inside, the lantern held high, and closed the door with the careful precision of someone trained in keeping things alive against impossible odds.

The nave was small, only a dozen paces from door to altar, the ceiling low and ribbed with black beams. The pews had been removed, but a row of mismatched chairs, parlor, kitchen, an old office seat with the stuffing exposed, formed a ragged congregation facing the chancel. At the far end, the altar was bare but for a single candlestick, flame guttering in the faint draft. 

Behind it, outlined in silhouette by the weak light, stood a man.