Copyright © 2025 by Christie Winter
All rights reserved.
No portion of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher or author, except as permitted by U.S. copyright law.
a candle in the window
Chapter 6: A Carol in the Fog
Midnight struck in increments, not as a single, clean bell but as a slow, chronic arrhythmia. Each chime traveled the frozen lane, found its way through the Harcourt house’s hibernating boards, and shuddered, at last, in the glass of Evelyn’s bedroom window.
The world outside was, in theory, familiar. She could reconstruct it by force of habit: the hedgerows stunted by the cold, the road made rigid under the white sheath, the church tower half-swallowed by fog and the day’s final round of snow. But when Evelyn pressed her forehead to the glass, the village was as blank as a cauterized wound. No stars, no lamplight, no movement, only the white static of flurried snow and the deeper, roiling gray of sea vapor. The blackout had rendered the street unrecognizable even to memory.
The only light in her room came from the lamp on her desk, a scavenged hospital sconce rigged with blackout cloth so that it illuminated only a small patch of her notebook and her left hand, fingers already stained with graphite from the pencil. The rest of the house lay in the kind of cultivated darkness only the English managed to perfect: every drape drawn, every stair creaking disavowed, the ambient noises of a family in retreat. Evelyn sat at her window, the candle stub from Tom’s room still clamped between her palms, waiting for some sign of recursion or renewal. She had not changed out of her day clothes, the nurse’s uniform stiff from cold, the overcoat still buttoned at the wrist as if to hold in the last of her body heat.
Somewhere downstairs, the ancient clock counted its way through the quarter-hour. It was too early for morning, too late for sleep. Evelyn counted the interval between chimes, let her mind rest on the rhythm. The church bell answered at the hour, then lapsed into silence.
She watched the street, as she had every night since the arrest, every night since the blackout began to feel less like a public health measure and more like the closing of a tomb. The only things that moved in this world were the thoughts she could not quiet. Sometimes she saw Tom’s shadow at the corner of her vision, sometimes the vague memory of a voice singing low and rough in the kitchen. She leaned her cheek against the glass, let the condensation cool her fevered skin, and considered whether there was any meaning in the world’s relentless subtraction.
That was when the singing started.
It was faint at first, a friction against the stillness, like wind rattling a seam or the distant hum of the rail line. She thought it might be a hallucination, the product of fatigue or hunger, but as she listened, the sound coalesced. A melody, slow and severe, wound its way up from the street, the notes paced with the precision of a metronome. “God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen.” The carol, rendered in a minor key, was stripped of all its comfort; it sounded as if the singers believed neither in mercy nor in the season.
Evelyn sat up, pressing her knuckles to the glass. Her eyes adjusted to the depth of the night, searching for movement on the lane below. At first, there was nothing, only the patternless drift of snow. But then, emerging from the fog, as if conjured, came a procession of figures, each wrapped in the uniform anonymity of wartime: heavy coats, scarves, gloves, their silhouettes rounded by the armor of wool and the ghostliness of the cold. There were six of them, perhaps seven, walking abreast in a careful, ceremonial line. They advanced at an even pace, boots silent against the snowpack, the music their only evidence of intent.
She watched as the group paused beneath her window. The voices, four male, two or three female, melded in a harmony too precise to be impromptu, the timbre oddly metallic, as if filtered through a radio even though she could see their breath crystallize on the air. No faces were visible; each wore a scarf drawn up to the bridge of the nose, each cap or hood pulled low, so that what appeared was not a choir but a file of medical mannequins, animate but incomplete.
They sang the first verse with perfect, metronomic fidelity. At the close, there was a deliberate pause, a full measure of rest, before the next verse began. This time, Evelyn heard it: a stutter in the phrasing, an elongation of the silence that seemed too intentional to be a mistake. Her nurse’s ear, trained to catch the arrhythmic, seized upon the change.
She closed her eyes, let her right hand hover over her thigh, and tapped out the rhythm against her knee. The pauses between phrases, she realized, matched the interstices of the hospital’s pulse monitor: short, long, then a cluster of shorts. Morse.
Her mind, reflexively, began to decode. Short, short, long, pause, long, short, short, short. S, V, then a break. She stilled herself, forced her breathing to slow, and listened to the next line. The singers, undaunted by the cold, kept to their tempo. Each verse ended with the same precise silence, the same implied signal.
She reached for her notebook, hands steady even as her heart threatened to break tempo. She wrote out the opening letters in pencil, marking the pauses between in the margin. SV, then another cluster, then a repeat. She mouthed the words with the singers, testing each note, measuring the space between.
On the third verse, the pattern shifted. A male voice, lower than the rest, stretched the word “Savior” into a prolonged drone, the note held just long enough to signal a dash in Morse. Evelyn underlined the line in her notebook, then transcribed the code as she heard it:
S ... short, short, short
A ... short, long
V ... short, short, short, long
I ... short, short
O ... long, long, long
R ... short, long, short
SAVIOR.
She felt her breath catch, and for a moment, her hand hovered above the page, unsure whether to continue. The choir did not stop. They cycled through the carol again, each repetition more deliberate, the pauses more explicit. Evelyn traced the letters with the edge of her pencil, watched as the message assembled itself beneath her hand.
Outside, the wind rose, carrying the next phrase up past the eaves and through the seams of the glass. The voices had lost none of their power; if anything, the cold made them sharper, a stiletto of sound against the silence. She looked down again, hoping for a glimpse of an unguarded face or a betraying gesture, but the fog had thickened, draping the group in a shroud so dense that it obscured even their footprints.
She wrote the next cluster:
R ... short, long, short
E ... short
M ... long, long
E ... short
M ... long, long
B ... long, short, short, short
E ... short
R ... short, long, short
REMEMBER.
Her pulse skittered. The message was not random. It had weight, and urgency, and a familiarity that made her scalp prickle. She recited the code in her head, now: SAVIOR REMEMBER, SAVIOR REMEMBER.
The choir lingered on the final verse, voices softening into a hum that was almost mechanical in its steadiness. They sang “tidings of comfort and joy,” but the line, stretched and elongated by the pauses, was anything but comforting.
Evelyn glanced at her hands, half expecting them to be trembling, but they were as steady as ever, the nurse’s discipline holding. She set the pencil down, then reached for the candle stub in her left hand, pressing the pad of her thumb into the cool, pitted wax. She glanced back at her notes, cross-referencing the code, then looked up through the pane.
The carolers stood in formation, the fog now so thick that only the outlines of their coats and the shimmer of breath gave evidence of life. As the last note died, Evelyn thought she saw the lead figure, tall, perhaps male, tilt his face up to the window, as if acknowledging her presence. There was no wave, no gesture, only the unbroken line of scarves and caps and the certainty that she was the intended audience.
For a moment, no one moved. The street, the night, the world itself seemed to wait. Then, without breaking rank, the carolers turned and filed down the lane, their boots erasing their own tracks, their voices dropping into a hush that, even as Evelyn strained, she could not follow. The only sound left was the low wind and the tick of the cooling house. She sat frozen, breath held, watching the spot where the figures had been until her eyes began to water with the effort.
When she finally exhaled, she found that her hands were no longer steady. The message, SAVIOR REMEMBER, hovered on the edge of her understanding, its meaning both urgent and incomplete. She copied the letters onto a new scrap, tore it from the page, and tucked it into her sleeve. Then she extinguished the lamp, lay back on the bed, and waited for her pulse to normalize.
Outside, the snow thickened, cloaking the street in silence. The clock, untethered from its echo, ticked on, marking the passage of a night in which nothing had changed, except perhaps everything. Evelyn stared into the dark, waiting for her eyes to adjust, and listened, just in case the carolers returned.
Unable to wait any longer, she got up, moving in the dark as she had once moved through triage: quickly, quietly, steps measured for both speed and certainty. The whole house conspired to keep her departure silent. The stairs, which had always creaked under Tom’s weight, yielded for her with only the faintest complaint. She found her coat where she’d left it, over the banister, still holding the heat of her last transit, and shrugged it on with a practiced roll of the shoulders. Boots next, the left one stiff at the heel but not enough to matter, and the right gliding on as if it had never belonged to anyone else. She looped her scarf, knotted it tight against the wind, and paused at the threshold, listening for any change in the stillness that might betray her mother’s waking or the intervention of fate.
Nothing. Not even the subtle rearrangement of air that signaled the movement of another person through the house. She took the lamp from its bracket in the vestibule, one of Tom’s “improvements,” a storm lamp retrofitted with a wind-hood and a reflector so that its beam could be shaped like a blade, and checked the oil level by the slosh of its tank. Two-thirds full, enough for an hour or more. She lit it with a match, shielded the flame with her palm, and watched as the glow stabilized into a clean, white arc that cut forward, barely touching the gloom.
Outside, the night was complete. The village was the inverse of itself: where once there had been houses and fences, now there were only ambiguous forms, new-formed drifts, and the suggestion of boundaries erased by snow. Her eyes adjusted to the world in stages. First, the steps, packed and icy, the recent snow swept to either side in low berms. Then, the lane itself, which ran straight and then curved hard at the baker’s, vanished into a hollow of mist. She held the lamp aloft, and the snowflakes leapt into motion, swirling in eddies like plankton under a microscope. The effect was disorienting, but beautiful, and for a second she thought of the old solarium at the hospital, where she’d once watched dust motes dance in the wedge of a sunbeam for the better part of an afternoon.
She stood at the gate, holding the latch in her gloved hand, and let the memories settle. The carolers were gone, of course they were, but their footprints remained: a latticework of prints pressed deep into the powder, the formation so precise that it looked premeditated, not the work of amateurs but of people used to moving as one. She stepped onto the walk, closed the gate behind her, and began to follow.
At first the prints ran together, muddied by the passage of so many boots, but as the group advanced down the lane, the pattern clarified. Each figure had walked with absolute economy, the gait even and spaced, not a single scuff or misstep. Evelyn counted the prints: seven, as she’d thought. The stride length was long for the leading pair, shorter for the two in the rear, but all were regular, almost military. The snow, while still falling, had not yet filled the tracks. She ran her finger along the edge of one, noting the sharpness of the impression, then checked her watch: less than fifteen minutes since she’d first heard the singing.
She followed the prints, lamp held chest-high, the arc of its light traveling forward and glancing off the walls of fog. The houses here were familiar to her, even stripped of their markers by winter. The Carroway place, with its double stoop and the black fence that Tom had once jumped in a single leap, then the narrow lot where the butcher lived, then the Vicarage, its front walk already buried. No other lights showed. No other sound, except for the creak of her boots and the soft, papery sigh of her own breathing.
She passed the Whitby place, its eaves sagging with the weight of snow, its window still fogged from whatever midnight ferment brewed within, and saw the footprints diverge slightly, a subtle bulge in the pattern as if the carolers had paused, or perhaps looked back. She swept the lamp over the verge, found nothing but a scattering of bird tracks and the collapse of a crusted drift, then pressed on.
The singing had faded with their departure, but as she walked, a fragment of it seemed to echo from the distance. Not a full melody, just the outline of voices, disembodied and swirling in the current of air. She listened for meaning, but the words were lost in the reverb of wind and the shifting shape of the village. Still, she catalogued the sound, assigning it to memory in case it returned.
As she neared the square, the fog thickened, reducing the radius of her vision to a few yards at best. The prints, though, were even clearer here, each one casting a small shadow in the lamp’s cross-beam. She followed them across the market, past the memorial where the flagpole, stripped bare, stood at salute against the white, and on toward the church.
The path bent left, then right, then straightened for the final approach. The churchyard itself was a black island in the snow, the stone wall standing two feet above the drift, the gate open and swaying on its hinges. The prints led directly to the entrance, then stopped.
She stood at the gate, swept the lamp over the ground, and frowned. The prints did not turn left or right; they did not scatter, or even show hesitation. They simply ended, as if the seven had walked into the air and vanished.
Evelyn stepped inside the gate, the iron cold even through her glove, and advanced three steps into the yard. She expected the tracks to resume, to see them continue toward the church door, but there was nothing, only the perfect, unbroken crust of new snow. She pivoted, lamp slicing the ground in arcs, and checked for any sign, trampled grass, melted patches, disturbance of any kind, but the space was clean. Even the wind, so insistent moments ago, was gone.
She looked up at the church’s belfry, half expecting to see a silhouette there, a watcher or a lookout, but the only thing visible was the shape of the bell, motionless against the fog.
She retraced her steps to the gate, considered the possibility that she’d missed a clue, then knelt and examined the final set of prints more closely. The snow around them was undisturbed, no sign of doubling back. She thought of the field hospitals, of men who had managed to bleed out under a blanket with no one noticing. Quiet, efficient, final. It was as if the carolers had never existed.
Evelyn stood, the lamp heavy in her hand, and looked once more across the yard. The only evidence of the group’s passage was the sequence of footprints, leading up to the gate, then ceasing.
She inhaled, the cold lancing her lungs, and let the data settle. The night offered her nothing else. No answers, no explanation, just the certainty that something had passed through, and that it had left neither residue nor witness.
She headed home before first light. The night had shifted, the snow less fierce but the fog coiled lower, hugging the ground with a ferocity that threatened to erase the entire lane by sunrise. Even with the storm lamp at her chest, she found herself doubting the existence of the path home: each step forward was a negotiation with the dark, a wager that the next indentation in the drift would still belong to the world she remembered.
But Evelyn could not let it rest. She stood for long minutes in the vestibule, the cold radiating through her boots, while she considered whether she should write up her observations immediately or wait for daylight. In the end, the nurse’s training won. She kicked off her boots, set the lamp on the washstand, and padded to her desk, every motion stripped to its minimum. She recorded the time, the duration of her absence, and the sequence of events in a single, unbroken line.
Then she considered the code. The memory of the carolers’ message, SAVIOR REMEMBER, still echoed at the base of her skull, persistent as a contusion. She wrote it out, underlined it, then set the pencil down and pressed her fingers to her temples, as if the answer to the puzzle might be coaxed out by sheer will.
She fell asleep at the desk, head pillowed on the notebook, and woke up with her cheek imprinted with the word REMEMBER. The lamp had guttered out in the night, but the morning was so dim that it made little difference. She went downstairs in a daze, the house as cold and silent as a morgue, and made tea with the mechanical certainty of a day nurse prepping for rounds. Her mother did not stir, lost to the sedative of age and the somnolence of winter.
It was not until she stepped out to fetch more coal from the shed that she saw the print in the snow, just beyond the point where the carolers’ tracks had vanished. It was not a footprint, not in the usual sense. It was a torn scrap of paper, half-embedded in the drift, the edges curled with cold.
She knelt beside it, lamp in one hand, and brushed the snow away with two fingers. The paper was cheap, the ink bled at the edges, but she recognized the type instantly. It was a hymnal leaflet, the kind the vicar distributed at the annual service. But this one had not been dropped by accident. The way it was positioned, pressed gently into the snow and pinned under a sliver of ice, suggested intentional placement.
She picked it up, careful not to tear the already fragile edge, and held it to the lamp. The paper was scored with faint lines, notes and lyrics, printed in the margin, but it was the markings along the border that seized her attention. Someone had drawn on the sheet, not with pen or pencil but with the point of a needle, or perhaps a scalpel: a series of dots and dashes, so fine that they might have been mistaken for flaws in the pulp, except that the sequence repeated every four centimeters along the edge.
She squinted, let her eyes adjust, and turned the leaflet under the beam. The code was unmistakable. Morse.
She ran her finger over the first cluster. Three dots, three dashes, three dots, SOS. It was so obvious in retrospect that she laughed, a short, bitter exhale of air that fogged up the glass of the lamp. She rotated the leaflet, found the next cluster. Dots and dashes, then a space, then more dots, then another pause. She copied the sequence onto her palm, muttering the translation aloud.
The message wrapped around the entire margin, like a thread stitched into a wound.
SAVIOR REMEMBER
MOTHER I AM SAFE
TRUST THE CHOIR
She nearly dropped the paper. The message was not for her. Or not only for her. It was for their mother, for the village, for anyone who knew the code. She read it again, slower this time. Each phrase is a separate line in the palimpsest. Savior, remember. Mother, I am safe. Trust the choir.
Her mind reeled back to the candle in Tom’s room, the message hidden in its base, the way the code had been delivered not with words but with song. The carolers, the precision of their march, when they vanished at the churchyard gate. She understood, then, that the entire performance had been an act of communication, a signal, not a ritual.
She looked up at the church tower, visible now through a rent in the fog, and saw that it was unchanged, the belfry cold and black, the bell inert. But she could feel, in the marrow of her arms, the presence of the message. It vibrated along her bones. She glanced left and right, the street empty except for the growing gray of the morning, then tucked the leaflet into her coat, flush against the heart.
A single chime rang out, brittle and precise, from the tower. It startled her so completely that she stumbled, nearly dropping the lamp. The bell tolled twice, then stopped. She rose, scanned the churchyard one last time, and hurried back to the house, the lamp’s light barely making a dent in the dark.
At the door, she paused, scanning the horizon for any movement. Nothing. Only the memory of the carolers’ harmony, still twined in her ear.
Inside, she locked the bolt, hung up the lamp, and sat at the desk with the leaflet in both hands. She set it beside the notebook, compared the margin code with the pattern from Tom’s candle, and saw that they matched, stroke for stroke.
She inhaled, exhaled, watched her breath float above the desk. She copied the new message into the notebook, the pencil making a sound like the crackle of frost. She underlined the message, then set the pencil down.
Her hands did not tremble. They were steadier than they had been in years. She folded the leaflet once, then again, and slid it into her sleeve.
Upstairs, her mother stirred and called her name. Evelyn did not answer, not at first. She sat at the desk, watching the light change, and waited for the bell to ring again.